Almost everyone has heard the Miranda warnings on television: "You have the right to remain silent..." But real cases often turn on details that television leaves out. Here are five misunderstandings that come up again and again.
1. "If police didn't read me my rights, my case gets thrown out."
Not usually. Miranda warnings are required before a custodial interrogation. If officers question you in custody without the warnings, the remedy is generally that your statements can be suppressed. The charge itself does not automatically go away, and other evidence, such as physical evidence or witness testimony, may still be used.
2. "They have to read my rights the moment I'm arrested."
The warnings are tied to interrogation, not to the arrest itself. Officers may arrest you and never question you, and they may never read the warnings. Statements you volunteer without being questioned are generally admissible even without Miranda warnings.
3. "Staying quiet is enough."
Courts have held that simply remaining silent may not be enough to invoke your right to silence. To be safe, say it out loud and clearly: "I am going to remain silent. I want a lawyer." Once you clearly ask for a lawyer during custodial questioning, officers are supposed to stop the interrogation.
4. "If I'm not under arrest, nothing I say counts."
Many of the most damaging statements are made before any arrest, during a "voluntary" interview or a roadside conversation. Miranda may not apply in those settings, but your words can still be used as evidence. You can decline to answer questions and ask to speak with a lawyer at any time.
5. "I already talked, so it's too late."
You can invoke your rights at any point, even in the middle of an interview. Stopping can prevent more harm. And a statement you already gave may still be challenged, depending on how it was obtained.
What to do
If police want to question you, be polite, do not resist, and clearly ask for a lawyer. Then let your lawyer evaluate what happened. Whether a statement can be suppressed depends on the specific facts: where you were, whether you were free to leave, what was said, and when.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different; to talk about yours, call 910-893-2900. Learn more about our criminal defense practice.
Free 6-page guideCharged With DWI in North CarolinaWhat happens after the arrest, what’s at stake for your license and your record, and the deadlines that matter in the first few weeks.Get the free guide →
← Older: How does North Carolina law enforcement conduct interrogations?
Newer: Are 401(k)s at risk during a divorce? →
