When a crash results in a death, the driver responsible may face criminal charges, such as misdemeanor or felony death by vehicle. The family may also bring a civil wrongful death claim. These are separate cases with different purposes.
Different goals
- The criminal case is brought by the State to punish wrongdoing.
- The civil case is brought by the estate to compensate the family for losses.
Different standards of proof
The criminal case requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The civil case generally requires proof by the greater weight of the evidence. A civil claim can succeed even if a criminal case ends in acquittal or dismissal.
How the cases interact
- Evidence developed in the criminal case, such as reconstruction reports, can be useful in the civil case.
- A guilty plea or conviction may help establish fault, depending on the circumstances.
- The defendant may decline to answer questions in the civil case while the criminal case is pending.
- Timing may need coordination, but the civil deadline does not pause for the criminal case.
The civil deadline
Wrongful death claims in North Carolina generally must be filed within two years of the date of death, even if the criminal case is still pending.
Restitution
A criminal court may order restitution for certain losses, but restitution rarely covers the full damages available in a civil case.
Victims' rights
North Carolina provides crime victims and their families certain rights, including notice of proceedings and the opportunity to be heard at sentencing.
A personal injury attorney can coordinate the civil claim with the criminal case, protect deadlines and pursue full compensation.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different; to talk about yours, call 910-893-2900. Learn more about our personal injury practice.
Free 6-page guideAfter a Car Accident in North CarolinaWhat to do at the scene, in the first week, and before you talk to an insurance company, plus the North Carolina fault rule that catches most people off guard.Get the free guide →
← Older: How divorce works in North Carolina: the basics
Newer: Felony murder in North Carolina →
