Free consultations for injury & medical malpractice cases
Mon–Fri 8:00–5:00728 S. Main St., Lillington, NC
Call the office910-893-2900
Blog

5 reasons you may choose litigation over settlement

Most civil cases settle before trial, and settlement is often the right choice. It saves time and expense and provides certainty. But settlement is not always in a client's best interest. Here are five reasons someone may choose to litigate.

1. The offer is not fair

Insurance companies and opposing parties sometimes make offers far below the real value of a claim, hoping the other side wants the case to end. When an offer does not account for real damages, such as medical bills, lost income or property loss, trial may be the better option.

2. Liability is disputed in a way that matters

When the other side denies responsibility and the evidence is strong, a judge or jury may be the right decision-maker. A trial can establish fault in a way a confidential settlement cannot.

3. A principle is at stake

Some disputes involve reputation, business practices or rights that matter beyond money. A public judgment may be important for a person or business.

4. The other side will not negotiate in good faith

Settlement requires both sides to engage honestly. When one side delays, refuses to exchange information or will not move from an unreasonable position, preparing for trial can be the only way forward. Often, serious trial preparation itself leads to a better settlement.

5. A clear legal ruling is needed

Some disputes, such as contract interpretation or property rights, may require a court ruling to resolve the issue for the future, not just the current disagreement.

Weighing the decision

Trial involves risk, time and expense. Juries can be unpredictable, and appeals can extend a case. A good decision weighs the strength of the evidence, the likely range of outcomes, the costs and the client's goals.

Why trial experience matters

Opposing parties evaluate whether a lawyer is willing and able to try a case. A firm that prepares cases for trial often negotiates from a stronger position, whether the case settles or not.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different; to talk about yours, call 910-893-2900. Learn more about our civil litigation practice.

Free 5-page guideSued, or Thinking About Suing? A North Carolina GuideWhat to do when you’re served, the deadlines that can decide a case before it starts, and how civil cases move through North Carolina courts.Get the free guide →

← Older: 6 surprising consequences of a DWI conviction
Newer: Social media during divorce: what to do with your accounts →

We fight to win. Let’s talk about your case.

Call 910-893-2900 or send a message to schedule a consultation.

Request a consultation